Dear Commissioner Mike Slive,
I know this has been a rough month for you. What with everyone suggesting that the SEC officials want to see Florida and Alabama in the SEC championship game no matter what the actual game results might be. Furthermore, I know that generally speaking the SEC's issue has been with judgment calls, celebration penalties on A.J. Green, personal fouls on some Arkansas defensive players -- it's okay, no one knows anyone's name that plays for Arkansas other than Ryan Mallet, it will be our secret -- missed calls in favor of Florida against Mississippi State, allowing Terrence Cody, the largest man on earth who still resembles a girl, to play without his helmet on. But this latest move, ignoring a clear interception by LSU's Patrick Peterson, has me steaming mad. What's the point of instant replay if you're going to use it and still get the play wrong?
That's why I'm making you an offer, I will work as instant replay reviewer for any televised SEC game.
For free.
Do you understand what a deal you're getting here, Commissioner Slive? I will work for the SEC for absolutely free. And I won't miss any calls.
Zero.
You know why? Two reasons, first, I don't care who wins the games (I'll gallantly recuse myself from University of Tennessee games) and, second, because I can watch television replays and tell whether or not people intercept passes. For instance, unlike your replay officials, I watched today's Alabama-LSU game. And when Patrick Peterson intercepted Greg McElroy with just under 6 minutes to play in the game, I said, "Wow, that's a hell of an interception."
You know how I knew?
Because like the rest of America, I saw Peterson catch the football and get not one, but two feet in bounds. That's one more foot in bounds than you actually need, Mr. Slive. Yet, somehow the
man you pay to sit in a booth and watch the replay didn't see this. He must have been blind ... or drunk. Perhaps he was both, so drunk he'd become blind. That's okay, I've been to Galette's before in Tuscaloosa and gotten that drunk. Although, to be fair, that's always been after a game. (Right, a FanHouse artist's concept of how SEC replays are currently performed.)
And here's my promise to you Commissioner Slive, I won't even drink during the games when I'm working as your replay official. I'll be stone cold sober. I won't even pause the television and look closely at the cheerleaders on the sideline. Do you know how hard it is not to do that?
And I won't pause my DVR and spend ten minutes thinking about how awesome it was the CBS camera caught a 'Bama fan with four fingers doing the fourth quarter sign as they went to commercial break.
Nope, I'm completely committed to the game.
I won't even spend any time thinking about the press conference I would stage if I were Les Miles. I'd load stacks of hundred dollar bills until I had 300 stacks, or $30,000 in all, into a black garbage bag and carry it into my press conference. Then, before I even said anything, I'd turn up the garbage bag and dump all the cash out onto the table in front of the reporters.
I'd let it all spill around on the ground and then I'd walk to the microphone and say this:
"Mike Slive can come pick up this money when he gets a chance. Because that official who blew that call in the replay booth doesn't deserve to ever work another game. We're not talking about a blown judgment call, or a decision made in the heat of the game when everyone is moving a million miles an hour. We're talking about a fat man sitting in front of a television and making a dispassionate decision based on what he sees.
"And he blew it.
"Big time.
"I'd sooner have Clay Travis making the decisions from his house in Nashville."
Amen, Les.
And, just think Mike, you'll get me for free.
How much worse can I really be?
By the way, just between us, could you please explain to me why the guy who does instant replay review actually needs to be in the stadium? Shouldn't he be in a special replay truck with 48 television screens? Or in a NASA-like center somewhere in a bunker beneath the ground in an undisclosed location? With a bank of television screens so large in front of him that the astronauts would be jealous?
Otherwise, doesn't it defeat the purpose? I mean, just to have one dorky guy sitting in a booth squinting at one television? Can't you do more with the multi-billion dollar contract? Shouldn't America demand that you do more?
Anyway, that may be too many questions. And I didn't write this letter to make your life more difficult Commissioner Slive. You and I, we should be buddies. We're both lawyers. I tan better than you do. (Seriously, do you ever go outside?) But other than that we're like two peas in a pod, you and me, Mike.
Except, you know, for the rooting for Alabama and Florida to be in the championship game part.
But I've gotten off topic. Instead of continuing about how much alike we are -- you like William Faulkner, Chik-fil-A sandwiches, the Robotech cartoon, and thongs on shapely rears too, don't you, Mike -- why don't you allow me to list my assets?
Yep, consider this my resume for SEC replay official status:
1. I have a color television.
And it's bought and paid for.
100 percent mine.
Judging by your guy at Bama's decision today, he doesn't have a color television. Otherwise he would have seen the clean distinction between a foot coming down in the green grass and a foot coming down in the white out-of-bounds area.
2. I have an HD television.
Again, if your guy had HD he would have seen the dirt popping up from not one, but two different feet in bounds.
3. I have the Internets in my house.
Of course, the Internets are brought to me by Comcast so at any moment they might stop working. Even still, I could theoretically watch the game online as well.
Why does that matter?
I could get to within a millimeter of the screen and zoom it up to perfect definition. That way I could confirm what I saw with my bare eyes: LSU intercepted that pass.
4. I've never taken money or bet on a game I was calling.
Did that one hit too close to the striped vest?
Good.
5. I have a law degree from Vanderbilt and am licensed to practice law in the Southland.
This means I'm an SEC grad whose judgment an impartial governing body has vouched for. Can you say the same about your officials?
Didn't think so.
It's a no brainer, Mike. Just shoot me an email and I'll be ready to go by next week.
Because as my five assets listed above illustrate, I'm much more qualified than most of the people working in the replay booth.
I look forward to hearing back from you.
Sincerely,
Clay Travis
Clay Travis is the author of three books. His latest, "On Rocky Top: A Front Row Seat to The End of an Era" chronicles the 2008 Tennessee football season and is on sale now.











Comments (Page 1 of 2)
Clay you as the rest of us on a lot of plays this year can't see what the review booth sees. But as for as CODY go back and read the rule book.... The play was over..... get on with it.... NO FOUL WAS THEIR FOR A RE KICK>>> get over it...
Now get the replay the booth had and shut the hell up... Alabama has never been the chosen team in the SEC... Check your history for the last 27 years since Bear has been gone.
The play was not over when Cody took his helmet off the ball was still rolling and there was time left on the clock. So a 15 yard penalty should have been called. I usually pull for the SEC to win BCS titles but not after this year. May Bama and Florida each lose a game before the championsip game so they wont go to the BCS championship game
Perhaps you should use that law degree for something other than being a sarcastic twit. I've watched Pac10, Big10 and ACC games and have seen officials blow all types of calls. Let's keep picking on the SEC because obviously we have nothing else better to do.
my thinkin is .the officals need to be tested for drugs,hell they call the plays on the players,lets make it even .one more thing how can an 59 year old man keep up with a 22 year old football player, lets test them, case n point
clay is right, the guy blew the call and i could care less about either school,but i did go to another game after that dumb call by the replay guy, its sad for all college football fans really, get it right. sad sick and sorry stuff
The SEC has the worst officials in the country. Florida and Alabama should both have one loss, mostly because the SEC teams suck.
screw you!!! many times Alabama has been on the other end of a Questionable call. Neither instance had an effect on the game. LSU had plenty of oppurtunity to win but couldn't get it done. i'ts FOOTBALL "A game of inches".
It was a terrible call. A chimp could have looked at that replay and got it right. That was an interception, period. I am a Pac 10 fan where the officiating is equally terrible. I have to believe there are people out there who would love the job of a replay official who can get it right. They don't get hired because the officiating is corrupt.
Does anybody realize that Florida Gators only beat LSU by a couple of points? Do you really consider them a National Chanpion Team? Alabama beat LSU by somehow getting "cheating" referees and someone that was obviously wanting Bama to win that was watching the replays. Do you really consider them a National Champion? Look at LSU-lost by a field goal. Lost by cheating. Bama made the winning touchdown after a wrong call was made
that turned the ball over to Bama. If LSU was able to keep the ball I can almost bet that $30,000 fine that Miles would have to pay had he approached that cheatin' referee that LSU would have won the game. CHEATERS NEVER WIN!!! Even with all the injuries LSU had I think they were the better team over Fla. and Bama. I would hope that most of the people in the stadium would also think that LSU intercepted the ball. Right Bama fans...Be truthful. The only fair thing is to replay the game with different referees and Mr. Clay as the instant replay man. That will never happen because Bama is afraid that LSU would win. Right? I am a victim of Multiple Sclerosis and I will never be able to go to a game and wouldn't want to go to watch games like that. I just wish commentators would stop talking against LSU at every game they play, before and after the game. Could it have anything to do with how good they were in the past and have been National Champions more than once, twice, or more. Sorry LSU. You will be champions again. Just work harder and try to get there next year.
everything you just said proves only one thing. you are s sore loser. But I think that you will get a lot more pratice.
Ugh - Unless someone has changed the facts to protect the innocent, I do believe that Florida beat LSU - IN BATON ROUGE - by Ten Points.
Bama - beats LSU - IN TUSCALOOSA - by Nine points.
Let me do some math here and home field analysis.
denise,
You and I must of watched different games---if I remember correctly the score was 13-3 ??? I call that losing by more than a couple of points.
denise tanner,
Maybe your wonderful LSU team lost to Alabama because they are like you---they are still living in the past talking about what could of been if they just had 3 more points at Florida ( but actually 10 more points )---why don't you just move on and concentrate on getting the job done instead of all the excuses of why your team can't get the job done. Plain and simple.
GOSH ,
but the babies do all cry at once dont they.TENN.your coach needs a diaper change . LSU.your coach needs a brain .the natural order of the SEC is back .[ did any 1 other than me notice that every time BAMA made a big play and started momentum a LSUser loser would lay down and fake an injury so lester miles could try to figure out a way 2 stop us ] PITY PITY PITIFULLLLLL BETTER LUCK NEXT TIME
I must put my two cents in here....The SEC is blatanly trying to set up an undefeated championship game to put an SEC team in the National Title Game...The SEC is obviously over rated and full of mediocre teams and a few decent teams...without the officials the east and west would be a mess with all teams having a few loses and no invite to the championship game and the money that comes with that invite. I dont just want to place this blame on the SEC. The Big 12 is doing the same team with Texas who has won several close games with the help of terrible officating. The blame lies with the BCS set up and the large dollars awarded to one of the 5 BCS Bowl games...and that isnt even enough now the Big 12 is proposing to let let the 6 major conferences to get births into the other bowl games over non BCS automatic qualifiers schools with more wins by claiming their wins are more important....And fianlly lets not leave ESPN blameless with their over the top coverage of the SEC and constant BS talk about how great the SEC is...I would also like to know how the ACC and Big East are considered better than the Mountain West or WAC confesrences...it must be a money thing again....If BSU and TCU win out it would and im sure because of the money involved will be a travesty that one of these teams are left out of BCS Bowl games in favor of a 2 loss team from a automatic qualifier school
Yhe problem with all those confrences is they dont play any good teams and they usally suck year end and year out. They win acouple of games a year by getting lucky and all of the sudden they should be equal with teams and confrences that do well on a consistant basis.
play a tougher schedule come to the sec more often and those mediocre teams will kick your butt.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=abuCLF7hJ6s
much better HD video of int, 100% indisputable moron in replay booth
Looked Like The Right Call to Me! It has be without a doubt that the call was wrong on the field for them to change it. It looks like his foot was on the chalk bye the replay. Sorry a picture a spot of torn up grass on the field is not part of the instant replay of the "Action on the field"
Oh Here's a Thought being as there are so many people that are arguing the Replay Call "Both Way's" Does'nt The Video Disputable? Thus Making The Call on The Field Stand!?
PS: LSU LOST!
SWEET HOME ALABAMA, ROLL TIDE ROLL!
:)